Insurance & legal

Car Accident While Working in Utah: Workers' Comp, PIP and the Other Driver

7 min read

You were on your way to a job site, making a delivery or running an errand your boss asked for, and another driver ran the light. Now you have two questions nobody answered at the scene: Is this a work injury or a car accident? And who pays?

In Utah, it can be both. If the crash happened while you were working, workers’ compensation will usually be involved, and the other driver can still be responsible. The order in which the coverages pay, and the notices you have to give, are different from a regular crash.

180 daysDeadline to notify your employer, or the claim can be barred (Utah Code § 34A-2-407)
66⅔%Of your average weekly wage paid during temporary total disability, up to a state cap
3 daysWaiting period for wage benefits, paid back if you miss more than 14 days
7 daysTime your employer has to report the injury to its insurer after you tell them
⚠️

Tell your employer right away, in writing if you can.

The Utah Labor Commission says to report a work injury immediately. Under Utah law, an employee who does not notify the employer within 180 days of the injury is barred from benefits. Waiting only makes it harder to connect the injury to the job.

Workers’ compensation covers injuries “arising out of and in the course of” your employment. For crashes, the question is what you were doing at the time:

SituationUsuallyWhy
Driving is part of your job (deliveries, sales calls, driving between job sites)Work-relatedYou were doing your job when it happened
An errand your employer asked you to runOften work-relatedThe trip was for your employer's benefit
Your normal commute to and from workUsually not coveredUtah courts apply the "going and coming" rule
Commuting in a vehicle your employer provides and controlsIt dependsCourts weigh the employer's benefit and control over the vehicle

The Utah Supreme Court has explained that accidents while going to and from work are generally not compensable, with exceptions, such as when the vehicle is an instrumentality of the employer’s business. These cases depend heavily on the facts, so if you are not sure, report it to your employer anyway and ask an attorney.

If you drive for Uber, Lyft or a delivery app, you may be classified as an independent contractor, which changes the picture. Read Uber or Lyft accident in Utah.

Who pays first: workers’ comp or PIP?

In a regular Utah crash, your own PIP pays your first medical bills. When the crash is work-related, Utah law says PIP benefits are reduced by any workers’ compensation benefits you receive or are entitled to receive for the same accident. In practice, workers’ comp usually carries the medical bills and part of the lost wages, and PIP fills in only what is left.

What workers' comp pays

  • Reasonable and necessary medical care for the work injury
  • Part of your wages while you cannot work: 66⅔% of your average weekly wage, up to a cap
  • No wage benefit for the first 3 days, unless you are out more than 14 days
  • Your employer may require your first visit with a preferred provider; after that, you can make a one-time change

What workers' comp does not pay

  • Pain and suffering
  • Your full wages
  • Damage to your car
  • In general, you cannot sue your own employer for the injury: workers' comp is the remedy

For how PIP works on its own, read who pays my medical bills after a car accident in Utah. For lost wages and protecting your job, see going back to work after an accident.

You can still claim against the other driver

Workers’ comp does not take away your claim against a driver who is not your employer or a coworker. Utah law allows you to receive workers’ compensation and bring an action for damages against the third party who caused the crash. Two things to know:

  • Your employer’s insurer gets paid back. If you recover money from the other driver, the workers’ comp carrier is reimbursed for what it paid, minus its proportionate share of the costs and attorney fees of the case.
  • You have to give notice. Before suing the other driver, you must give written notice to the workers’ comp carrier so it can take part.

This is one of the situations where coordinating three coverages — workers’ comp, PIP and the at-fault driver’s insurance — really benefits from an attorney.

What to do in the first week

  • Report the injury to your supervisor or HR and keep a copy or a text message showing the date.
  • Ask your employer for the workers' comp insurer's name and your claim number.
  • Tell every provider that you were working when the crash happened.
  • Also report the crash to your auto insurer.
  • Keep the police report, photos and witness information, just like any other crash.
  • Go to every appointment: gaps in treatment are used against you in both claims.

The short version

If you were working when the crash happened, workers’ compensation will usually pay first and PIP is reduced by what workers’ comp pays. Report the injury to your employer right away — the legal deadline is 180 days, but waiting hurts your case. Your normal commute usually does not count. And you can still claim against the driver who caused the crash, although the workers’ comp insurer will be reimbursed from that recovery.


This article is general information about Utah law and is not legal advice; how it applies depends on the facts of your case. If you were in a car accident in the Salt Lake City area, Car Injury Clinic (Taylorsville, UT) offers same-day evaluation, free transportation and coordination with your attorney. Call 385-242-8571 or book an appointment.

Were you in a car accident?

Same-day evaluation, free transportation and legal support in Taylorsville, UT.

FAQSchedule onlineCall nowWhatsApp