Treatment

Ibuprofen or Tylenol After a Car Accident? Using Over-the-Counter Pain Relievers Safely

6 min read

The night after the crash your neck is stiff and your lower back aches, so you take a couple of ibuprofen. A week later you are still taking them every few hours, and you have added Tylenol “for the bad moments.”

Over-the-counter pain relievers can help you get through the first days. But they do not heal the injury, they can hide how bad it is, and taking them for weeks has real risks. Here is what to know before you open the bottle.

4,000 mgMaximum acetaminophen per day from all sources combined (MedlinePlus)
10 daysIf pain lasts longer while taking OTC ibuprofen, stop and call your doctor
17 vs 16Median days to recover from acute low back pain with acetaminophen vs placebo, in a trial of 1,652 people
20 weeksOf pregnancy, after which ibuprofen should not be taken unless your doctor says so
🚨

Get emergency help right away if you have:

Chest pain, shortness of breath, weakness on one side of the body or slurred speech · vomit that is bloody or looks like coffee grounds, or black, tarry stools · you think you took too much acetaminophen, even if you feel fine.

And if the pain is severe, keeps getting worse, or comes with numbness, weakness or a headache that will not go away, a pain reliever is not the answer: you need an evaluation.

The two main types of OTC pain relievers

Acetaminophen (Tylenol)NSAIDs: ibuprofen (Advil, Motrin), naproxen (Aleve)
What it doesRelieves pain and feverRelieves pain, fever and inflammation
Main riskLiver damage if you take too muchStomach ulcers and bleeding; higher risk of heart attack and stroke
Hidden trapIt is in many cold, flu and prescription pain medicines, sometimes labeled "APAP"Risk is higher with high doses, long use, older age, smoking and alcohol
Ask before taking if you…Have liver disease or drink three or more alcoholic drinks a dayTake blood thinners, have had ulcers or stomach bleeding, have heart or kidney disease, are pregnant or are 75 or older

MedlinePlus warns not to take more than 4,000 mg of acetaminophen a day from all sources, and not to take more than one product containing acetaminophen at a time. That limit is easy to pass without noticing if you combine Tylenol with a “nighttime” cold medicine or a prescription pain pill that already contains it.

For NSAIDs, MedlinePlus notes that the risk of a heart attack or stroke can appear at any time during treatment and may be higher with long use or high doses, and that ulcers and bleeding can happen without warning symptoms. Pregnant? Read pregnant and in a car accident. Caring for an older parent? See older adults after a car accident.

What the evidence says about pills for back pain

For acute low back pain — one of the most common injuries after a crash — the American College of Physicians recommends starting with non-drug treatments: superficial heat, massage, acupuncture or spinal manipulation, because most people improve over time regardless of treatment. If medication is wanted, the guideline recommends NSAIDs or muscle relaxants.

Acetaminophen did not do well in that setting. In a large randomized trial of 1,652 people with acute low back pain, the median time to recovery was 17 days with regular acetaminophen and 16 days with a placebo — no meaningful difference. That does not mean it never helps anyone, but it is a reason not to rely on it alone.

Read more in heat, ultrasound and massage, or exercise? and back pain after a car accident.

Muscle relaxants and driving

If a doctor prescribes a muscle relaxant such as cyclobenzaprine, know that it can make you drowsy. MedlinePlus advises not to drive or operate machinery until you know how it affects you, and to ask your doctor about alcohol, because it can make its effects worse. MedlinePlus also says older adults usually should not take cyclobenzaprine, because other medicines are safer or work better for them.

Masking the pain is not the same as treating it

  • It can hide a worsening injury. Pain that is “under control” with pills every few hours is still pain. Tell your provider how much you are taking, not just how you feel on it.
  • It can delay care. Some injuries show up over days. See delayed symptoms after a car accident.
  • Frequent painkillers can cause headaches. MedlinePlus warns that taking pain medicines more than 3 days a week may lead to rebound headaches. Read headaches after a car accident.
  • It does not restore movement. Stiffness and weakness after a crash usually need active rehab. See your first six weeks of rehab after a crash.

If you take pain relievers after a crash

  • Read the label and follow the dose. Do not take more or more often than directed.
  • Check every product you take for acetaminophen, including cold medicines and prescriptions.
  • Tell your provider about blood thinners, heart, kidney or liver problems, ulcers or pregnancy.
  • Write down what you take, how much and whether it helped. It is useful for your provider and for your claim.
  • If you still need them after about 10 days, or the pain is getting worse, get evaluated.

The short version

Acetaminophen and NSAIDs like ibuprofen can make the first days after a crash more bearable, but they do not treat the injury. Stay under 4,000 mg of acetaminophen a day from all sources, ask before taking NSAIDs if you have heart, kidney or stomach problems, take blood thinners or are pregnant, and do not drive on a new muscle relaxant until you know how it affects you. If you are still reaching for pills after about 10 days, it is time for a real evaluation.


This article is informational and does not replace an individual medical evaluation or the advice of your doctor or pharmacist about your medications. If you were in a car accident in the Salt Lake City area, Car Injury Clinic (Taylorsville, UT) offers same-day evaluation, free transportation and coordination with your attorney. Call 385-242-8571 or book an appointment.

Were you in a car accident?

Same-day evaluation, free transportation and legal support in Taylorsville, UT.

FAQSchedule onlineCall nowWhatsApp